Main menu For students For teachers Explore our subjects Student events & courses

Teaching Economics

Exam Support

A* Evaluation Arguments on UK Monetary Policy

Geoff Riley

18th November 2026

Share this content:

This revision video considers six evaluation points as to the effectiveness of a period of higher interest rates in controlling inflation. While the Bank of England's commitment to its 2% inflation target is clear, applying a conventional demand-side squeeze to an unconventional supply-side problem is fraught with limitations. Download the free powerpoint if you want a teaching resource.

A* Evaluation Arguments on UK Monetary Policy

On November 5th, the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) voted 8-1 to raise the Bank of England base rate to 4%. With UK CPI inflation recently hitting 3.5% and the Bank forecasting a peak of around 5% by the middle of next year, the central bank has clearly felt compelled to act.

But, we must ask a critical evaluation question: will higher borrowing costs actually cure this specific inflationary disease?

The primary driver of our current inflation is an external, supply-side shock. Specifically, global energy prices remain high and volatile due to the ongoing conflict in the Middle East. The Bank of England has explicitly raised rates to prevent these rising energy costs from spilling over into broader domestic prices. However, interest rates are inherently a demand-management tool. A 4% base rate cannot resolve geopolitical supply chain bottlenecks, nor can it drill for more oil or refine more natural gas. By using a blunt demand-side instrument to fight a cost-push shock, the MPC risks suppressing consumer spending and business investment without addressing the root cause of the price level increases. In fact, higher borrowing costs could actively discourage the capital investment required to build long-term domestic energy resilience.

Furthermore, the monetary transmission mechanism operates with notoriously long time lags. It generally takes up to two years for a rate hike to fully filter through the macroeconomy. If the Bank is tightening policy now to combat energy-driven price spikes, the full deflationary impact will not be felt until late 2028. By that time, the initial supply shock may have dissipated. This raises the real danger of policy overshooting, potentially tipping a fragile UK economy into an unnecessary recession long after the inflationary spark has faded.

Finally, the structure of the UK mortgage market blunts the immediate impact of the MPC's decision. While borrowers on variable or tracker rates will see their monthly repayments increase immediately, millions of households are insulated by fixed-rate mortgages and will not feel the pinch of the 4% rate until their current deals end. This delayed reaction softens the immediate reduction in aggregate demand that the Bank is hoping for.

Stay Happy, Stay Positive, Stay Curious.

Download this PowerPoint

Share this content:

Geoff Riley

Geoff Riley FRSA has been teaching Economics for nearly forty years. He has over twenty years experience as Head of Economics at leading schools. He writes extensively and is a contributor and presenter on CPD and Revision conferences in the UK and overseas.