motivation in practice - performance related pay - teachers
In a controversial move in the UK education sector, the Department for Education has insisted that teachers' pay must be linked to performance as part of its plans to “modernise” public sector services - including workplace reform.
In its 2003 submission to the School Teachers Review Body, the Department for Education said teachers could not expect an above-inflation pay increase in 2004. The department is also considering giving individual schools more power to set pay rates for their staff.
A spokesman for the department said:
" The government is strongly of the view that the priority for this year is not a general increase in pay above the rate of inflation but instead action to promote workforce reform and tackle workload issues."
In 2002, the government introduced a performance-related bonus scheme in order to boost teachers' pay and help retain staff. Experienced teachers can apply for a one-off bonus of £2,000. Currently, almost all teachers who apply for the performance pay get it. They can only apply after they have taught for six years.
Study suggests performance related pay is inappropriate for teachers
However, a recent study has suggested that there is no evidence that paying teachers performance bonuses leads to better exam results or attracts more recruits to the profession.
Researchers from the Institute of Education in London found little evidence to suggest the payments had improved results or attracted more people into teaching.
The study argued that it is difficult to determine the impact of any one teacher on a pupil's progress.
" A pupil may have private tuition, help at home, or any number of external influences. So we may never know objectively whether performance-related pay has positive effects on pupil learning outcomes” said Professor Dalton, a co-author of the study.
The researchers even argue that bonus payments could be counter-productive because teachers were used to working together instead of competing with each other.
The researchers say it is a "difficult if not impossible task" to devise a performance-related pay system for teachers that makes them work harder and more productively, does not need expensive monitoring, encourages teamwork and discourages teaching to the test.
Other countries, including the USA, have paid teachers performance bonuses but the study suggests they provide little convincing evidence for or against performance-related pay.
Professor Dolton said: "Market theories do not necessarily work in the public sector. A bricklayer may lay more bricks if paid a bonus, but this does not apply to teachers, who are highly motivated professionals already working to maximum capacity."
Source: Adapted from articles in the Daily Telegraph and Independent, 2002
tutor2u Home Page | Online Store | Contact Us | About tutor2u | Copyright Info | Your Privacy | Terms of Use
Working with Our Partners Sapphire Education | Learning Curve | Vue Cinemas | Moneypenny | Nexcess | Really Simple Systems | Actinic | Bickster Boston House | 214 High Street | Boston Spa | West Yorkshire | LS23 6AD | Tel +44 0844 800 0085 | Fax +44 01937 529236 Company Registration Number: 04489574 | VAT Reg No 816865400 tutor2u is proud to sponsor TABS Cricket Club and Collingham JFC as part of its programme of investment in local junior sport |
