Disadvantages of direct democracy
Recommend on Google+
There’s a great article in the xmas double issue of the Economist on the perils of direct democracy. A useful source of arguments and examples for those covering the UK and US participation in politics modules.
The pros and cons of more extensive use of direct democracy were discussed by both my AS and A2 groups at the end of last term. This article serves to reinforce the conclusion we came to: that the theory of bypassing legislatures and granting the people a greater degree of control over policy making was a nice idea in theory, but the US state level experience showed that it is likely to be hijacked by the same wealthy and well organised groups that have traditionally dominated. Thus it serves merely to entrench elitisim in the US rather than enhance pluralism.
In a UK sense, the consensus my group that I have covered this topic with concluded that they would look forward to the opportunity to have more say over changes to the constitutional apparatus, such as Lords reform, the various EU treaties, etc but agreed that legislators would probably be best placed to look at complex fiscal and social issues since they are the professionals. In order to free up more time for MPs to study issues in more detail, it was agreed that burdensome constituency responsibilities should be transferred away from MPs offices to either independent bodies and/or local government.
blog comments powered by Disqus
AS Politics: direct democracy [24 Oct 2011]
Nick’s journey [15 Feb 2011]
A real alternative? [5 Jan 2011]
To AV or not AV (that is one of the questions)? [18 Nov 2010]
Federalism in action [26 Jul 2010]
Referendums in the United Kingdom [21 May 2010]
Federalism: advantages and disadvantages [4 Oct 2009]
AS revision: MPs’ expenses [20 May 2009]
AS revision: UK pressure groups and democracy [17 May 2009]
Quality, not quantity [15 Sep 2008]
House of Lords reform: what’s the argument? [22 Aug 2008]
Blood on the streets [20 Jun 2008]
Tony Benn on democracy [1 Mar 2008]
POLITICS TEACHER RESOURCE NEWSLETTER
Join over 1,600 Politics Teachers who receive the regular tutor2u Politics Teacher Resource Newsletter by email.
