Separation, schmeparation???

I’ve been blogging quite a bit recently on Separation of Powers, as we’re teaching it as part of Sources of Law. It’s widely accepted that our system is far from perfect as far as this goes. However, today’s story in the Guardian is a frightening example of, perhaps, how power is still actually wielded in the back corridors of Whitehall and the Courts. Read on for more details, the letter in question and a video clip.

Even in a judgment that in itself is critical of the Government and has ruled their refusal to disclose information on allegations of MI5’s complicity in torture unlawful, it turns out that parts of the Court of Appeal’s judgment were changed after representations made by the government’s lawyers!

Whilst it seems that the judgment may now be re-worded again to reflect its original contents, the fact that this can happen at all calls into question the idea of separation of powers as well as the independence of the judiciary.

You can read the letter in question here. A great way to get your students to question much-vaunted ideas like judicial independence and the separation of powers.

Quality problems for the judiciary? [8 Dec 2011]
The Supreme Court - VIDEO [26 Oct 2011]
Must-read! [11 Oct 2011]
Judges reading the Riot Act [19 Aug 2011]
Asian people 42 times more likely to be stopped and searched…. [24 May 2011]
Supreme Court to rule on meaning of miscarriage of justice [9 May 2011]
Supreme Court video clips [6 Apr 2011]
Judicial Diversity and the Supreme Court [30 Mar 2011]
A British Bill of Rights? [23 Mar 2011]
Judicial Review and abuse of power [11 Feb 2011]
Cuts and judicial independence [9 Feb 2011]
Judicial Review [25 Jan 2011]
Video: Ken Clarke on the Magna Carta [14 Nov 2010]
North Sea Oil and Judicial Review [5 Oct 2010]
Will the Supreme Court survive the cuts? [24 Sep 2010]
Lord Bingham [12 Sep 2010]
Legal Heroes [18 Aug 2010]
Government policy on deportation “unlawful” [27 Jul 2010]
Judicial diversity [5 Jul 2010]
Al Rawi and Others v Security Service and Others [7 May 2010]
New Supreme Court Justice [31 Mar 2010]
Separation of Powers [6 Feb 2010]
A Primary Example of Bad Legislation [3 Feb 2010]
Gillan and Quinton v UK [12 Jan 2010]