Juries and mental illness
Recommend on Google+
Under the Juries Act 1974, people undergoing treatment for mental health problems are not permitted to serve on a Jury. Mental health charity Rethink are campaigning for a change in the law from a blanket ban to a test based on capacity as defined in the Mental Capacity Act 2005. An interesting way to start a discussion of the topic with your students. If they need a celebrity angle (!) Stephen Fry is one backer of Rethink’s campaign.
Under current legislation, Rethink argues, many capable people are not permitted to serve, including luminaries such as Stephen Fry, who has the following to say about it:
“There are thousands of people with mental health problems who are willing and perfectly capable of serving on a jury but who find themselves rejected solely because they see a doctor from time to time for support or medication. Exclusion purely on the grounds of treatment for a mental health problem is unfair and discriminatory, and eliminates a whole tranche of law abiding, competent individuals who should be entitled to play their part in the justice system.”
There’s a good article by Clare Allen on this here which would make useful extension material.
Jury trial under threat…again! [17 Jan 2012]
A landmark case for the jury [20 Jul 2011]
Jury trial and the internet [16 Jun 2011]
Silk… [23 Feb 2011]
Free interactive resource! [25 Jan 2011]
Twitter Joke Trial [22 Nov 2010]
Guardian Law [13 May 2010]
Magna Carta [22 Mar 2010]
Are juries fair? [21 Feb 2010]
Juries and the web [26 Jan 2010]
Coroner’s Courts [24 Jan 2010]
First criminal trial without a jury for 400 years to go ahead next week [8 Jan 2010]
Great story for English Legal System revision generally… [7 Dec 2009]
Reform of libel law [22 Nov 2009]
LAW TEACHER RESOURCE NEWSLETTER
Sign up for the free Law Teacher Resource Newsletter from tutor2u
