Unintended consequences of the smoking ban

Saturday, February 09, 2008
by Geoff Riley
Print

Any government intervention in the market can give us cause to consider the Law of Unintended Consequences where a policy decision or action leads to fresh actions which might not have been considered by those putting a policy in place. Some of these knock-on effects can be positive, a windfall that enhances the impact of the original decision. Others can be negative leading to fears of government failure and a deepening of an existing problem or market failure. The smoking ban seems to be providing a rich seam of examples of such unintended blow-back effects.

There is growing evidence that the smoking ban has had a major impact on cigarette consumption among certain groups. But some of the side effects are starting to become apparent. One is the rising mountain of litter created by the millions of cigarette stubs casually tossed aside by smokers forced out into the open air because of the ban on smoking in ‘enclosed areas’. This BBC news audio-visual clip provides a vivid and nifty illustration of the problem.

A second negative unintended consequence has been a surge in demand for and use of open-air patio heaters, widely regarded as a very inefficient way of providing heating for patrons of pubs, clubs and restaurants and which are very energy intensive contributing to C02 emissions. A typical pub patio heater emits more than 4 tonnes of C02 emissions per year, more than the average car. Some superstores now refuse to sell patio heaters. here is another BBC news audio-visual clip on the heated topic of patio warmers.

Can you think of other side-effects of the smoking ban that might come under the banner of ‘unintended consequences’?

Euro MPs back patio heaters ban

Print Digg it Del.icio.us My Yahoo RSS

ECONOMICS TEACHER RESOURCE NEWSLETTER

Join over 4,000 other Economics Teachers in the UK and around the world who receive the tutor2u Economics Resource Email newsletter. Get special offers, first news of latest resources, teaching ideas, conferences and workshops.

*  Your Email Address:
*  Preferred Format:
    AS/A2 Economics Board:
    GCSE Economics Board:
*  Country:
    Full Name:
    Job / Position:
    Postcode:
    School / College:
    Town / City:
*  Enter the security code shown:





Comments

One consequence, perhaps not completely unintended, is the growing control of government over people’s everyday lives.  You control people by controlling their pleasures--look at the millenia-old attempts by various power structures to control sexuality.  The antismoking, antidrinking, antifat nanny state arrives at the same time as the security state with its surveillance cameras and proposals for implanted chips.  None of it adds up to anything positive.

Posted by  on  02/10  at  06:54 PM

I have heard stories about nightclubs pumping air freshener into their venues to mask the smell of sweat which tobacco used to cover up. Obviously there are many other examples of complements/substitutes who have been affected like this.

Posted by  on  02/11  at  06:48 AM

Name:

Email:

Location:

URL:

Smileys

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Submit the word you see below:


Most Popular Topic Tags on the Economics Blog

recession, demand, unemployment, inflation, prices, price, economics, costs, investment, profit, downturn, confidence, supply, trade, euro, competition, debt, gdp, employment, housing, expectations, risk, oil, capacity, sterling, china, incentives, production, exports, manufacturing, property, food, profits, mortgage, pay, tutor2u, globalisation, revision, slowdown, banks, borrowing, emissions, usa, retailers, dollar, airlines, deflation, efficiency, aqa, elasticity, consumption, welfare, economist, monopsony, innovation, supermarkets, productivity, depression, wealth, carbon, depreciation, environmental, cars, stocks, opec, jobs, saving, management, evaluation, tim harford, construction, macroeconomics, behavioural, environment, poverty, bank of england, credit crunch, losses, eu, externalities, competitiveness, steel, inequality, stagflation, monopoly, moodle, commodities, entrepreneur, bbc, contestable, cpi, protectionism, currencies, survey, farming, google, taxes, minimum wage, keynes, subsidy, spare capacity, regulation, dan ariely, skills, climate change, strategy, infrastructure, itunes, lse, vle, choices, pollution, aviation, newsnight, carbon trading, agflation, economic cycle, pricing, imports, population, rpi, mpc, shipping, london, interest rates, rationality, government failure, stakeholders, market failure, amazon, collapse, current account, oligopoly, suppliers, output gap, reputation, cartel, japan, shareholder, intervention, shareholders, global, surplus, keynes society, robert peston, capital, fiscal stimulus, vat, budget deficit, coffee, redundancies, economies of scale, edinburgh, discrimination, ownership, balance of payments, oecd, nationalisation, petrol, savings, price discrimination, eurozone, multiplier effect, starbucks, income elasticity, wages, development, liquidity, behavioural economics, subsidies, merger, germany, budget, labour market, discounting, exploitation, behaviour, ecb, free, smoking, facebook, rsa, heathrow, open source, hotels, poland, single market, blog, monetary policy, leverage, information failure, northern rock, indirect tax, waste, growth, robert frank, milk, federal reserve, happiness, freight, forecast, quiz, animal spirits, scarcity, india, transport, paul mason, kaletsky, apple, trade deficit, takeover, currency, tesco, information, brand, etonomics, hbos, cost of living, income elasticity of demand, needs, internet, libor, taxation, nissan, microsoft, opportunity cost, deficit, wants, fairness, wiki, poverty trap, renewable, companies, corus, coal, devaluation, imf, pubs, brazil, obesity, duopoly, foreign exchange, res, consumer surplus, consumer welfare, uk economy, ocr economics, cost benefit analysis, russia,
All tags



Get a daily email update of new resources on the Economics Blog

Discussion forums for Economics teachers

Follow tutor2u on Twitter

 Jim  | Geoff  | Others

Latest entries

Categories

Monthly Archives

Syndicate