New to AS Business ( BUSS1/BUSS2) | Step Up to A2 Business (BUSS3 / BUSS4)
The Downsides of Downsizing - Does Retrenchment Work?
Some good evidence in this HBR blog article about downsizing - a term commonly associated with the strategy of retrenchment. The article refers to a recent piece in the Wall Street Journal predicting that many already “lean” and successful firms are considering further retrenchment as they aim to cut costs and streamline their operations.
The HBR blog outlines some possible downsides of such retrenchment. These are good arguments to use in an essay when analysing and evaluating whether retrenchment is the right strategy for a firm that is struggling.
The key points are:
- Downsizing often leads to worse, not better, financial performance
- Downsizing damages the working environment in the firm, adversely affecting the morale and motivation of those left behind, which in turn can lead to lower productivity and creativity.
- Employees who are retained (i.e. not laid off) have lower loyalty to the business, resulting in a risk of higher staff turnover amongst employees that the business wants/needs to keep
A similar argument to the above is made by Freek Vermeulen of the London Business School.
http://www.businessweek.com/managing/content/may2009/ca2009051_612010.htm
Vermeulen quotes from Fortune Magazine which commented firms that downsize, who:
“rather than becoming lean and mean, often end up lean and lame.”
Strategy: Kazou Hirai and the Forgone Bonuses [1 May 2013]
BUSS4 - Want Good Analysis? Think How & Why? [29 Apr 2013]
Strategy: Kazou Hirai’s First Year as CEO of Sony [22 Apr 2013]
Internet firm opens up ‘google’ style office [11 Apr 2013]
Changes in culture and leadership at Yahoo spells trouble for teleworkers [1 Mar 2013]
Kinaesthetic Motivation - On Sale Now! [27 Jan 2013]
Retrenchment Strategy - Are Things Looking Better for Nokia and Stephen Elop [10 Jan 2013]
Hard HRM v Soft HRM - Mark’s Tough Approach is Bad News for Joe [16 Dec 2012]
Ansoff and Tesco - What Went Wrong with Fresh and Easy? [6 Dec 2012]
More Retrenchment as Panasonic Tries to Stem the Losses [15 Nov 2012]
Argos’ Transformational Plan - But Is It Too Late? [7 Nov 2012]
Sit Down Herzberg!!!! [25 Oct 2012]
Maslows Sunday Roast [10 Oct 2012]
ResearchBuster: Retrenchment [26 Sep 2012]
More Evidence of Retrenchment as Cost Cutting Bites [11 Sep 2012]
Retrenchment - Lexmark Exits the Inkjet Printer Market [29 Aug 2012]
Motivation at Work - What Makes Employees Go the “Extra Mile”? [24 Aug 2012]
Another good reason to work at Google - Pay when you Die! [10 Aug 2012]
Retrenchment in the Public Sector [18 Jun 2012]
Sony - Can Hirai Turn the Business Around? [16 Jun 2012]
Retrenchment in Greece - Carrefour sells out for one euro [16 Jun 2012]
More Retrenchment at Nokia (June 2012) [14 Jun 2012]
Nokia and Strategic Change - the Essential A2 Business Case [14 Jun 2012]
Motivation, Culture and Productivity - the Google Way [29 May 2012]
Creating a motivational workplace [28 May 2012]
Revision Presentation - Training [17 May 2012]
It’s all going wrong for Nokia - big losses in Q1 (2012) [20 Apr 2012]
Sony - Hirai’s Turnaround Strategy - in Video Clips [13 Apr 2012]
Revision Presentation - Retrenchment [4 Apr 2012]
Retrenchment: Short-Term Pain for Long-Term Gain? [19 Mar 2012]
Two Lesson Videos on Nokia - Will their Strategy Work? [13 Mar 2012]
Happiness in the workplace still proving elusive [6 Feb 2012]
Leadership - Tough decisions to turn Starbucks around [29 Jan 2012]
Unemployment and motivation [28 Dec 2011]
Thomas Cook begins down the long road of retrenchment [14 Dec 2011]
Thomas Cook opts for a different generic strategy for success [11 Dec 2011]
Ho! Ho! Ho? No No No! Motivation and the Xmas Party [4 Dec 2011]
Retrenchment not enough as the lights go out for Luminar [6 Nov 2011]
The Simpsons and Financial Motivation [11 Oct 2011]
De-layering: do firms need middle managers? [5 Oct 2011]
Tesco and Retrenchment [31 Aug 2011]
Motivation in a time of austerity - financial benefits become more important [27 Jul 2011]
The costs of redundancy [5 Jul 2011]
Retrenchment for Thorntons following strategic review [28 Jun 2011]
Mothercare’s change of strategic focus - Updated [13 Jun 2011]
Retrenchment in action - Comet turns off the retail lights [12 May 2011]
CSR - Can better social responsibility boost the UK economy by £17bn? [12 May 2011]
HMV to become a more ‘compact’ disc retailer [6 Apr 2011]
Partners in profit - the JLP way [10 Mar 2011]
8 minutes of Daniel Pink on What Motivates Workers [7 Mar 2011]
The end of the line for JJB? [13 Feb 2011]
Q&A - What is absenteeism and what can businesses do about it? [28 Dec 2010]
Starbucks - Two Examples of Financial and Non-Financial Methods of Motivation [19 Dec 2010]
Bruce Poon Tip exploits a huge Gap in the adventure market [12 Dec 2010]
Will a price war and snow finally kill off JJB Sports? [3 Dec 2010]
A great example of off-the-job-training - Starbucks Coffee College [16 Oct 2010]
Rationalising & Redeployment at Alliance Boots [9 Oct 2010]
Maltesers and Motivation [8 Oct 2010]
Can performance-related pay motivate the SCD celebs? [18 Jul 2010]
Is this the worst job in the world? [15 Jul 2010]
Are fringe benefits being cut? [5 Jun 2010]
Linking corporate objectives to management performance - the Vodafone way [4 Jun 2010]
Managing People - Will Staff Turnover Increase as the UK Emerges from the Recession [2 Jun 2010]
Flexible Working More Popular than Bonuses as a Source of Staff Motivation [2 Jun 2010]
The Dark Side of the iPad and iPhone? [26 May 2010]
Motivation, Leadership & Culture: Ban the Boss (BBC) [24 Mar 2010]
Motivation and management at John Lewis [12 Mar 2010]
BUSS4 Research - a Corus of Disapproval [1 Mar 2010]
Retrenchment at the BBC [26 Feb 2010]
Strategy in the UK Recession - What 69 UK CEOs Did About It [22 Feb 2010]
Money as a motivator in social work? [20 Feb 2010]
Teaching strategy - Starbucks revisited [24 Jan 2010]
Revision presentation - motivation in theory [17 Jan 2010]
Revision presentation - motivation in practice [17 Jan 2010]
Retrenchment and capacity cutting at Blacks Leisure - and then expansion again? [12 Jan 2010]
Teaching Motivation - Classic Video(s) [17 Dec 2009]
Starter Video Clip for Motivation [17 Nov 2009]
A tale of two bakers [16 Nov 2009]
The UK: A nation of accidental managers [10 Nov 2009]
Q&A - What is Leadership? [30 Oct 2009]
Auto Warriors - the Capacity Management Reality Show [28 Oct 2009]
Leadership styles in action - Dead Poets Society [28 Oct 2009]
Motivation in action - the stairs theory [12 Oct 2009]
Forget motivation theory - lets try to demotivate people [5 Oct 2009]
Motivation in practice - how not to do it - lessons from Britain’s bosses [1 Sep 2009]
Flexible unemployment [19 Jun 2009]
Work For Free? Or Pie In The Sky? [16 Jun 2009]
Q&A - Explain “delayering” [1 Jun 2009]
Motivating employees - the end of the mobile phone sales shark? [17 May 2009]
Motivation in Action - Is this the Worlds Best Job? [7 May 2009]
Q&A - What is job enlargement? [1 May 2009]
Q&A - Explain Taylor’s theories of motivation at work [1 May 2009]
Q&A - How does a business benefit from having a well-motivated workforce? [1 May 2009]
Q&A - What is motivation? [1 May 2009]
Small businesses in the middle of the crunch - insights for students [22 Apr 2009]
Segmentation strategy - Halfords abandons premium retail brand [16 Apr 2009]
Video case study - Google’s Non-Financial Methods of Motivation [6 Feb 2009]
Linking customer service and motivation theory [2 Feb 2009]
Video case study - starting a business in a recession [24 Jan 2009]
Arsene Wenger reveals the secrets of successful teamwork [24 Sep 2008]
blog comments powered by Disqus
Business Studies Revision / Exam Coaching Workshops Coming Up:
GCSE Business (AQA Unit 2 & Edexcel Unit 3)
Thursday 24 April 2014 - Birmingham
Friday 25 April 2014 - London (Stratford City)
AQA AS & A2 Business (BUSS1 & BUSS3)
Monday 20 January 2014 - London (Stratford City)
Tuesday 21 January 2014 - London (Fulham Broadway)
Wednesday 22 January 2014 - Bristol (Cribbs Causeway)
Thursday 23 January 2014 - Birmingham (Star City)
Friday 24 January 2014 - Manchester (Salford Quays)
AQA AS & A2 Business (BUSS2 & BUSS4)
Tuesday 25 March 2014 - London (Stratford City)
Wednesday 26 March 2014 - London (Fulham Broadway)
Thursday 27 March 2014 - Bristol (Cribbs Causeway)
Friday 28 March 2014 - Birmingham (Star City)
Tuesday 1 April 2014 - Newcastle (Metro Centre)
Wednesday 2 April 2014 - Leeds (The Light)
Thursday 3 April 2014 - Manchester (Salford Quays)
Post-Easter (BUSS1/BUSS2 Combined & BUSS4)
Monday 28 April 2014 - London (Stratford City)
Tuesday 29 April 2014 - London (Fulham Broadway)
Wednesday 30 April 2014 - Bristol (Cribbs Causeway)
Thursday 1 May 2014 - Birmingham (Star City)
Friday 2 May 2014 - Manchester (Salford Quays)
Try some of these superb starter activities for Business Studies:
- Anagram Countdown
- Beat the Teacher
- Bellwork
- Budget Basket
- Memory Challenge
- Loop Cards
- I'm the Question
- Catchphrase - Say What You See!
- Consider All Possibilities (C.A.P)
- i-Teach
- Teacher Talkabout
- Perfect Recall
- Pass the Buck
- What would you have invented?
- These are a few of my favourite things
- Set Your Students the 15 Word Challenge
- Topic Tennis
- What Why Depends - Developing Thinking Skills
Join our Business Teacher Email Newsletter
Join our community of over 15,000 Business Teachers & Lecturers who receive our Business Teaching Resource Newsletter
| Business Studies Blog | Economics Blog |
| Geography Blog | Politics Blog |
| Give It A Go! Blog | Sociology Blog |
