Protecting a business idea - Bratz hit by copyright damages

Whilst not strictly about protecting a start-up’s business idea, here is a good example of a company that has fallen foul of the protection offered by copyright laws…

Mattel, perhaps the world’s leading toymaker, has been awarded significant damages in a copyright case against MGA, the maker of the rival Bratz dolls.  This BBC news article has more information.

A court in California ruled that the creator of Bratz dolls, Carter Bryant, came up with the idea while he was working for Mattel, and so the idea actually belonged to his employer.

The payout is thought to be at least $40m (£22m) but Mattel, which makes Barbie, had asked for about $2bn.

To put the damages into perspective, MGA are believed to be making annual profits of around $500 on Bratz.

Barbie herself has long been in the decline phase of her product life cycle.  Barbie was orginally launched in 1959 and Mattel have kept the brand strong with a compehensive collection of product extensions.  However, sales are now in decline, particularly in the core US market.

Marketing case study: the Swiss Army knife [24 May 2012]
Revision Presentation - Marketing Mix: Introduction to Products & Brands [17 May 2012]
Revision Presentation - Marketing & the Product Life Cycle [17 May 2012]
Takeovers and Mergers - the failed takeover behind Clinton Cards’ Collapse [9 May 2012]
What’s going wrong at Superdry? [23 Apr 2012]
The Apprentice and the Product Life Cycle [23 Mar 2012]
An embarrassment of riches: what does Apple plan to do with its cash mountain? [22 Mar 2012]
VW targets growth markets [26 Feb 2012]
Kit Kat Chunky Champion [20 Feb 2012]
The history of Apple’s product innovation - in 30 seconds [10 Feb 2012]
Private equity buyouts - Sunday Times supplement [5 Feb 2012]
The 7p Valentines Day Card [1 Feb 2012]
How to turn threats into an opportunity at Ryanair [31 Jan 2012]
Crazy Frog-Great example of a targeted marketing mix? [28 Jan 2012]
What’s gone wrong for Kodak? [19 Jan 2012]
The Rise and Fall and Rise of Gerald Ratner [27 Nov 2011]
Who do you think should be named Brand of the Year 2011? [22 Nov 2011]
Ipod sales - does this graph look familiar? [17 Nov 2011]
A trip down memory lane for a great business studies resource [3 Nov 2011]
Halloween, Google+ and the product life cycle. [1 Nov 2011]
Revision Quiz - Marketing: Products & Brands [1 Nov 2011]
Revision Quiz - Creating & Protecting Business Ideas [21 Oct 2011]
Lesson starter video: Technological innovation in the post-PC era [15 Oct 2011]
Can you copyright a dance move? [12 Oct 2011]
Messy Contributions…. recipe for success? [29 Sep 2011]
Product Life Cycle - The Blue Peter Annual [22 Sep 2011]
Insights on invention from Trevor Bayliss [14 Sep 2011]
Product life cycle - the meltdown of ice cream vans [31 Aug 2011]
Some graphics for the product life cycle and social media. [14 Jul 2011]
ResearchBuster: Technology and Change [14 Jun 2011]
Banned in Denmark, but Marmite still available in Harrogate, Eastbourne, Cheltenham and the UK. [24 May 2011]
Changing demand in the market for live music [16 May 2011]
MySpace and the product life cycle [27 Mar 2011]
Revision games - Marketing Basics (True / False) [16 Feb 2011]
Michael Porter - Shared Value and the Limitations of CSR [15 Feb 2011]
Starter activity - Name that brand [9 Jan 2011]
Q&A - What are key parts of product life cycle theory? [29 Dec 2010]
Q&A - Why do most businesses sell more than one product? [29 Dec 2010]
Justin King on the Sainsbury’s Brand [21 Dec 2010]
BUSS1 Revision Quiz - Generating and Protecting a Business Idea [14 Dec 2010]
Dominos Pizza - Growth & Strategy (Part 1) - Driving Competitive Advantage [26 Nov 2010]
Revision Crossword - Product Basics [6 Nov 2010]
How long is the product life cycle? [25 Oct 2010]
Gap’s new logo lasts…one week [12 Oct 2010]
When is a Ping not a Ping? When its an Apple [1 Sep 2010]
37 Ways for a Business to be More Competitive [24 Aug 2010]
Sony’s Product Development Timeline [13 Jul 2010]
Toyota UK fights back with tv & Youtube advertising campaign on quality [26 Jun 2010]
Long Product Life Cycles - Grocery Brands Stand the Test of Time [26 May 2010]
Strategy Case Study - Diversification for the Bread Family [21 May 2010]
Hard luck Emma - Beaten by a Short Product Life Cycle [19 May 2010]
Product Life Cycle in Action - The Bill gets The Chop [26 Mar 2010]
Into the clouds - is this the end of the life cycle for pen drives? [14 Mar 2010]
Are these really Britain’s most disliked brands? [17 Feb 2010]
The Museum of Brands - well worth a visit [14 Feb 2010]
Revision Quiz - Marketing Mix (20 Questions) [12 Feb 2010]
Licence to Chill [6 Feb 2010]
Masking the product life cycle [2 Feb 2010]
Product, pricing and profitability in a changing market [20 Jan 2010]
Celebrity books - in the decline phase of their product life cycle? [15 Jan 2010]
Innovation - Is Entertainment Letting Us Down? [2 Jan 2010]
Technology transforms business in the Noughties [30 Dec 2009]
Video Case Study - Luxury Sound Maker Ditches CDs [4 Dec 2009]
Entrepreneur takes advantage of the postal strike [24 Oct 2009]
Are Cool Brands Really Cool? [29 Sep 2009]
Patent Theft threatens enterprising inventors [3 Sep 2009]
Is reinventing Polaroid really an “impossible project”? [1 Sep 2009]
One year left in the product life cycle of big brother [27 Aug 2009]
A dramatic fall in business investment [27 Aug 2009]
Product life cycle - end of the line for Teletext [17 Jul 2009]
Microsoft and Google compete head-to-head [9 Jul 2009]
Spare capacity prompts a fall in business investment [4 Jul 2009]
Q&A - Outline the main costs and benefits of inflation [1 Jul 2009]
The Life Of Big Brother [3 Jun 2009]
Q&A - What factors influence the choice of a sales forecasting method? [31 May 2009]
Protecting a business idea - the irn-bru way [26 May 2009]
Business strategy video - two interviews with CEO of Virgin Atlantic [26 May 2009]
Q&A - Why are start-ups vulnerable to cash flow problems? [26 May 2009]
Q&A - How is profit used by a business? [26 May 2009]
M&S suffers a fall in profits and cuts dividend [23 May 2009]
Q&A - What is meant by Social Enterprise? [22 May 2009]
Product life cycle - which technologies will soon be declining into the scrap heap? [20 May 2009]
Q&A -  What is share capital [2 May 2009]
Q&A - What is the link between product differentiation and a USP? [1 May 2009]
Q&A - What is profit-sharing? [1 May 2009]
Q&A - What are retained profits? [1 May 2009]
Q&A - What causes an exchange rate to change? [1 May 2009]
Q&A - Explain what is meant by a product [1 May 2009]
Q&A - What goes into the “marketing mix”? [1 May 2009]
Q&A - What is a sole trader? [1 May 2009]
Q&A - What is a cash flow forecast? [1 Apr 2009]
Social networking and the product life cycle [5 Mar 2009]
Q&A - What is profit and why is it important? [1 Mar 2009]
Q&A - What are the advantages to a start-up of being a franchise? [1 Mar 2009]
Blue Peter - End of its Product Life Cycle? [10 Feb 2009]
Q&A - What is a brand name and what are the advantages of having a strong brand? [1 Feb 2009]
The business with an interest bill of £2.2m per day [30 Jan 2009]
Video Case Study - Product Life Cycle of the Standard Light Bulb [12 Jan 2009]
A good example of over-optimistic sales forecasting [10 Jan 2009]
Video Case Study - Exporters Benefit from a Weaker Pound [6 Jan 2009]

BUSINESS TEACHER RESOURCE NEWSLETTER
Get first news of business teaching resources, ideas and other materials from tutor2u. Over 9,400 business teachers from the UK and around the world receive our regular teacher email newsletters. Sign up for free here!