Partners in profit - the JLP way

We’ll be asking many of our students a simple question over the next few months.  Is profit good? Is profit maximisation a strategy for greed?  I wonder how the partners at John Lewis might respond to that question…

Anyone who doubts the potential for financial methods of motivation ought to watch this brief news video from Reuters.

The knowledgable business student will know that there is something different about John Lewis Partnership.  The business is owned by its employees (partners), not by distant, external shareholders. As part of the organisational structure, employees at JLP share a profit pot for their annual bonus.  Everyone gets the same percentage (%) bonus, calculated as a % of their annual basic pay.

This is what happened when the bonus percentage for payment in 2011 was announced to JLP staff.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2tX2GiDm5Ug

Bonus Day at JLP is a big day for staff. The 18% bonus announced for 2011 reflected a big rise in profits in 2010. 

The video makes some good points about the motivational impact and role of a profit bonus.

But will the announcement in 2012 lead to the same scenes of excitement?  Even JLP (considered the bellweather of UK retailing) has admitted that trading in the early part of 2011 has been weak.

Revision Presentation - Measuring and Increasing Profit [17 May 2012]
Revision Presentation - Training [17 May 2012]
Revision Presentation - Calculating and Measuring Profit [13 May 2012]
The Downsides of Downsizing - Does Retrenchment Work? [4 Apr 2012]
Happiness in the workplace still proving elusive [6 Feb 2012]
Leadership - Tough decisions to turn Starbucks around [29 Jan 2012]
Still more praise for the “John Lewis model” [17 Jan 2012]
Unemployment and motivation [28 Dec 2011]
Ho! Ho! Ho?  No No No! Motivation and the Xmas Party [4 Dec 2011]
The Rise and Fall and Rise of Gerald Ratner [27 Nov 2011]
Cut price cup cake deal goes wrong…... [22 Nov 2011]
Unilever hit by rising costs [6 Nov 2011]
The Simpsons and Financial Motivation [11 Oct 2011]
De-layering: do firms need middle managers? [5 Oct 2011]
Profits dive and put pressure on liquidity - the Distress Monitor [29 Sep 2011]
Revision Presentation - Risks and Rewards to Enterprise [7 Sep 2011]
Revision Presentation - Adding Value [7 Sep 2011]
The puzzle of rising profits [5 Sep 2011]
Motivation in a time of austerity - financial benefits become more important [27 Jul 2011]
CSR - Can better social responsibility boost the UK economy by £17bn? [12 May 2011]
8 minutes of Daniel Pink on What Motivates Workers [7 Mar 2011]
Stuff the banks - John Lewis issues a retail bond [6 Mar 2011]
Introducing a new kind of business organisation - the benefit corporation [17 Feb 2011]
CSR - What is “Creating Shared Value”? [16 Feb 2011]
Michael Porter - Shared Value and the Limitations of CSR [15 Feb 2011]
CSR - The Classic Milton Friedman Clip [5 Feb 2011]
Q&A - What is “profit quality”? [7 Jan 2011]
Q&A - What is absenteeism and what can businesses do about it? [28 Dec 2010]
Starbucks - Two Examples of Financial and Non-Financial Methods of Motivation [19 Dec 2010]
Bruce Poon Tip exploits a huge Gap in the adventure market [12 Dec 2010]
Dominos Pizza - Growth & Strategy (Part 3) - Smart Marketing [26 Nov 2010]
Dominos Pizza - Growth & Strategy (Part 2) - Innovation, Service and Smart Operations [26 Nov 2010]
Dominos Pizza - Growth & Strategy (Part 1) - Driving Competitive Advantage [26 Nov 2010]
Cash flow Clue-doh! The Mystery is Revealed… [2 Nov 2010]
Profits up at Amazon - but so are costs [22 Oct 2010]
Bonus system to encourage safety improvements at BP [20 Oct 2010]
A great example of off-the-job-training - Starbucks Coffee College [16 Oct 2010]
Google, Profits and Diversification [16 Oct 2010]
Maltesers and Motivation [8 Oct 2010]
Lesson Worksheet - Adding Value [10 Aug 2010]
Lesson Worksheet - Gross Profit Basics [5 Aug 2010]
Can performance-related pay motivate the SCD celebs? [18 Jul 2010]
Is this the worst job in the world? [15 Jul 2010]
Are fringe benefits being cut? [5 Jun 2010]
Linking corporate objectives to management performance - the Vodafone way [4 Jun 2010]
Managing People - Will Staff Turnover Increase as the UK Emerges from the Recession [2 Jun 2010]
Flexible Working More Popular than Bonuses as a Source of Staff Motivation [2 Jun 2010]
The Dark Side of the iPad and iPhone? [26 May 2010]
Profit seeking paradoxes in an oblique world [15 May 2010]
Pricing strategy in action - John Lewis (video) [25 Mar 2010]
Motivation, Leadership & Culture: Ban the Boss (BBC) [24 Mar 2010]
Motivation and management at John Lewis [11 Mar 2010]
Strategy in the UK Recession - What 69 UK CEOs Did About It [22 Feb 2010]
Money as a motivator in social work? [20 Feb 2010]
Revision Presentation - Profit and Cash [30 Jan 2010]
Revision Presentation - Improving Profit [30 Jan 2010]
Product, pricing and profitability in a changing market [20 Jan 2010]
Revision presentation - motivation in theory [17 Jan 2010]
Revision presentation - motivation in practice [17 Jan 2010]
An interview with the boss of John Lewis [8 Jan 2010]
Revision Quiz - Profitability & ROCE [6 Jan 2010]
Revision Presentation - the Basics of Profit [30 Dec 2009]
Teaching Motivation - Classic Video(s) [17 Dec 2009]
Financial motivation at British Airways - Cabin Crew Pay Compared [16 Dec 2009]
Outdoor Ice-skating heads firmly down the product life cycle [3 Dec 2009]
Advertising Coming To A Windows 7 Desktop Near You [18 Nov 2009]
Starter Video Clip for Motivation [17 Nov 2009]
The UK: A nation of accidental managers [10 Nov 2009]
Innocent Drinks - Teaching Accounts Exercise [9 Nov 2009]
Q&A - What is Leadership? [30 Oct 2009]
Leadership styles in action - Dead Poets Society [28 Oct 2009]
Entrepreneur takes advantage of the postal strike [24 Oct 2009]
Motivation in action - the stairs theory [12 Oct 2009]
Forget motivation theory - lets try to demotivate people [5 Oct 2009]
The Decline of Newspapers Creates a Surge in Local Startups [4 Oct 2009]
V-Water - from start up to exit [4 Oct 2009]
The dramatic slump in advertising revenue continues [18 Sep 2009]
Todd Stitzer’s Strategic Test [14 Sep 2009]
Motivation in practice - how not to do it - lessons from Britain’s bosses [1 Sep 2009]
Product life cycle - end of the line for Teletext [17 Jul 2009]
How to improve profitability? - give customers a “staff appraisal” [12 Jul 2009]
Coffee Republic struggles with the daily grind [6 Jul 2009]
What makes a profitable menu? [6 Jul 2009]
Spare capacity prompts a fall in business investment [4 Jul 2009]
Q&A - Outline the main costs and benefits of inflation [1 Jul 2009]
Q&A - Explain the causes of inflation [1 Jul 2009]
Q&A - Explain the role of corporate objectives in business strategy [1 Jul 2009]
Nationalisation Again - National Express Taken into Public Ownership [1 Jul 2009]
A Mars A Day The Original Recipe Way [28 Jun 2009]
Budget Hotel Chain Now Feeling the Squeeze [17 Jun 2009]
Work For Free?  Or Pie In The Sky? [16 Jun 2009]
A stunning example of how wage costs can differ for the same job [10 Jun 2009]
How to improve a profit margin through a hidden price increase - the Snickers way [4 Jun 2009]
Q&A - Explain “delayering” [1 Jun 2009]
Britain’s Got Talent - Extending the Brand [1 Jun 2009]
Sources of finance - the bank overdraft rip-off [28 May 2009]
Q&A - Why are start-ups vulnerable to cash flow problems? [26 May 2009]
Q&A - How can a business handle a loss? [26 May 2009]
Q&A - How is profit used by a business? [26 May 2009]
Why businesses fail - an interview with Pepita Diamand [24 May 2009]

BUSINESS TEACHER RESOURCE NEWSLETTER
Get first news of business teaching resources, ideas and other materials from tutor2u. Over 9,400 business teachers from the UK and around the world receive our regular teacher email newsletters. Sign up for free here!