OCR 2880 (ACE) - Why build a railway line when a bus will do?

One of the strategic choices facing students in the OCR 2880 case study is a potential project to build a railway line linking the ACE airport to the national rail network. Here’s what the real-life airport behind the case study has actually done when faced with the same challenge.

The business in question is East Midlands Airport.  Back in 2007, planning permission was finally given for Network Rail to build East Midlands Parkway, a new “green” railway station which has been built one mile from junction 24 of the M1 motorway and next to the A453 that connects Nottingham, to the M1 and East Midlands Airport. The station opened in January 2009.

How has East Midlands Airport responded to the new station?  Build a spur link directly to the airport?

No.  it has taken a much cheaper, simpler option. It has set up a transfer bus service, linking the airport to the railway station.  A short 15 ride on a regular shuttle bus service brings passengers directly to the terminal.

Sounds like a smart move to me.  It avoids a substantial investment risk and minimises the loss of lucrative car parking revenues.  Yet it still provides an environmentally-friendly service for customers who wish to travel to the airport via the rail network.  If demand proves greater than expected, then simply add more shuttle buses to the service. Like so many things in business strategy, think KISS - “keep it simple stupid”!

Takeovers and Mergers - the failed takeover behind Clinton Cards’ Collapse [9 May 2012]
Revision Presentation - Managing Risk [7 Apr 2012]
UK manufacturing - GlaxoSmithKline invests in 1,000 new jobs [22 Mar 2012]
Pampering - demand booms as consumers seek an affordable treat [4 Mar 2012]
Lesson video : Franchising for beginners [4 Mar 2012]
Buying-in to the Facebook culture [5 Feb 2012]
Investment in People - Google and Human Capital [26 Dec 2011]
Revision Presentation - Workforce Planning [26 Dec 2011]
Time for this Dragon to Cut Costs to Keep his Health Clubs Fighting Fit [11 Dec 2011]
International operations decisions - Adidas trainers for $1? [26 Nov 2011]
Cut price cup cake deal goes wrong…... [22 Nov 2011]
Revision Presentation - Risks and Rewards to Enterprise [7 Sep 2011]
Tesco pulls out of Japan [4 Sep 2011]
Risk-free Curry? Searching for the Right Growth Strategy [29 Aug 2011]
Luke Johnson on sources of finance for a startup [29 Aug 2011]
Entrepreneurs and Calculated Risks [25 Aug 2011]
Evaluation in business essays?  Its just like going on a date… [22 Aug 2011]
Samsung seeks a ban on Apple products [30 Jun 2011]
Business investment: the UK corporate cash pile [15 Jun 2011]
Changing demand in the market for live music [16 May 2011]
Jaguar goes for NPD investment with £5bn plan [10 May 2011]
Life in the chocolate factory - automation, productivity, motivation and culture [24 Apr 2011]
Kate & Wills - A Short-term boost to demand [9 Apr 2011]
The UK Economy - Business Investment [14 Mar 2011]
Protection for the endangered pasty [23 Feb 2011]
Commodity prices in action - soaring Copper [6 Feb 2011]
Start-ups - a surge in new businesses post recession [2 Nov 2010]
Bonus system to encourage safety improvements at BP [20 Oct 2010]
Making the FT Brand Sweat! [19 Oct 2010]
Analysing the Business Data - Marriage in Decline [19 Oct 2010]
Businesses argue the case for greater investment in public infrastructure [16 Oct 2010]
Culture & Change - The Challenge Facing Nokia [27 Sep 2010]
Who ate all the pies? [17 Sep 2010]
Strategy in Action - Crocs Comes Back from the Dead [4 Sep 2010]
Lesson Worksheet - Enterprise & Entrepreneurs [9 Aug 2010]
Lost in translation - demand from public sector to dry up? [4 Aug 2010]
Nissan profits from a recovery in demand [30 Jul 2010]
Demand for Foreign Holidays Takes a Sharp Dip [14 Jul 2010]
World Cup 2010 Business Winners and Losers [13 Jul 2010]
New BBC Resource: Start Up Stories [25 Jun 2010]
BUSS4 data - what happened to business investment in the UK recession? [14 Jun 2010]
Is the mega-merger falling out of fashion? [7 Jun 2010]
Emerging from Recession - Manufacturing Leads the Way [1 Jun 2010]
The dangers of focus on one product [9 May 2010]
Corus chief calls for more government funds for the economy [8 Apr 2010]
Recession Survival Strategies Cost UK SMEs £16bn [31 Mar 2010]
BUSS4 Research - a Corus of Disapproval [1 Mar 2010]
Marketing in a recession: more focus on brand advertising and product enhancements [20 Feb 2010]
Managing a recruitment business through the recession [16 Feb 2010]
Taking Demand-based Pricing To Extremes [8 Feb 2010]
Video case study - substitute goods benefiting from the recession [1 Feb 2010]
Strategy in a recession - Fusion Systems [1 Feb 2010]
Business priorities in a recession [1 Feb 2010]
Demand and Supply in Sction - Haggis [25 Jan 2010]
Product, pricing and profitability in a changing market [20 Jan 2010]
Q&A - Is there an optimal level of gearing? [5 Jan 2010]
Revision Quiz - Gearing [5 Jan 2010]
Revision Presentation - Revenues and Demand [30 Dec 2009]
Video Case Study - Luxury Sound Maker Ditches CDs [4 Dec 2009]
Outdoor Ice-skating heads firmly down the product life cycle [3 Dec 2009]
Emerging markets drive demand for oil [16 Nov 2009]
Survive and prosper - emerging markets in the global recession [5 Nov 2009]
Emerging Markets - China’s Growth in Charts [5 Nov 2009]
Buffett Bets on the Railways [5 Nov 2009]
Emerging Markets - 10 Tips on Successful Market Entry Strategy [5 Nov 2009]
Halloween - packed full of business studies lesson ideas [3 Nov 2009]
Innovation & Protecting a Business Idea - Classroom Video [30 Oct 2009]
Q&A - What is globalisation? [27 Oct 2009]
Q&A - How are businesses affected by unemployment? [27 Oct 2009]
Q&A - What are the main causes of unemployment? [27 Oct 2009]
Q&A - Explain what unemployment is and how it is measured [27 Oct 2009]
Managing Cash Flow - Beware the Economic Recovery [26 Oct 2009]
4 minutes with Stelios - insights into entrepreneurship [24 Oct 2009]
Strictly and X-Factor Drive Demand for Pizza [1 Oct 2009]
The lights go out for the nightclub market [26 Sep 2009]
A textbook example of how rising unemployment affects demand [23 Sep 2009]
Demand is booming for UK Cinemas [16 Sep 2009]
Can you spot the next ‘disruptive technology’? [7 Sep 2009]
How to beat the tourism competition?  Be the “steepest” [31 Aug 2009]
Video case study: battling for survival in the restaurant trade [31 Aug 2009]
A dramatic fall in business investment [27 Aug 2009]
Strategic business decision-making - Network Rail [26 Aug 2009]
Demand and supply in action - tea prices surge [4 Aug 2009]
When the Steel Town Boomed [3 Aug 2009]
BA cuts out the cost of short-haul meals [29 Jul 2009]
One-handed eating changes the demand for knives [20 Jul 2009]
Business angels take flight - just when small businesses need them [12 Jul 2009]
Welsh Business Benefits from the Ashes [8 Jul 2009]
Spare capacity prompts a fall in business investment [4 Jul 2009]
U2 on Tour - Investment appraisal and capacity utilisation rolled into one! [2 Jul 2009]
Q&A - Outline the main costs and benefits of inflation [1 Jul 2009]
Q&A - Explain the causes of inflation [1 Jul 2009]
Q&A - Explain the role of corporate objectives in business strategy [1 Jul 2009]
Recession Bites - new food shopping habits [29 Jun 2009]
Budget Hotel Chain Now Feeling the Squeeze [17 Jun 2009]
Building a tourist facility on the top of a mountain [12 Jun 2009]
Porter’s Five Forces hits the fish counter [10 Jun 2009]
Thinking Outside The Smaller Box [8 Jun 2009]
Apprentice Stars Lack Entrepreneurial Spirit [4 Jun 2009]
Do The Dragons Get It Right? [1 Jun 2009]

BUSINESS TEACHER RESOURCE NEWSLETTER
Get first news of business teaching resources, ideas and other materials from tutor2u. Over 9,400 business teachers from the UK and around the world receive our regular teacher email newsletters. Sign up for free here!