Money as a motivator in social work?
Saturday, February 20, 2010
Print
Email
Tweet This!Save to Favorites
Recommend on Google+
The government has a new scheme to attract more high-flyers to the profession of social work - particularly needed as recent high-profile and tragic cases such as that of Baby P have made it hard to recruit social workers. The carrot they are offering is cash - the new ‘Step up to Social Work’ scheme offers graduates at least £15,000 to retrain as children’s social workers under a new government-funded scheme. Candidates must have at least a 2.1 degree and some experience already of working with children and families, and this report says that it will be “up to local authorities who are employing those trainees to decide how to use the money” - they will receive the money from the Children’s Workforce Development Council (CWDC), which receives most of its funding from the Department for Children, Schools and Families. So the money is not exactly paid directly to the 200 new recruits - there is a complicated bureaucracy which gets involved first.
There are a number of issues relevant to recruitment, training and motivation that strike me here:
- this is an example of how poor reputation of the employer makes it hard to attract good candidates for vacancies
- Herzberg makes it very clear that hygiene factors (including money) are just as important as the motivators; is money the most appropriate form of motivation for this kind of job?
- what impact is this offer likely to have on morale amongst those already employed in the social work profession?
blog comments powered by Disqus
A light-hearted look at induction training [6 Feb 2012]
Happiness in the workplace still proving elusive [6 Feb 2012]
Leadership - Tough decisions to turn Starbucks around [29 Jan 2012]
The cost of recruitment [3 Jan 2012]
Unemployment and motivation [28 Dec 2011]
Investment in People - Google and Human Capital [26 Dec 2011]
Ho! Ho! Ho? No No No! Motivation and the Xmas Party [4 Dec 2011]
Recruitment Law - Don’t get caught on the hop [21 Nov 2011]
Job Production…Unwrapped [10 Nov 2011]
Lesson video - a day in the life of a supermarket [20 Oct 2011]
The Simpsons and Financial Motivation [11 Oct 2011]
De-layering: do firms need middle managers? [5 Oct 2011]
Strategies for success on the beleaguered high street [6 Sep 2011]
Corporate culture meets recruitment [28 Aug 2011]
Motivation in a time of austerity - financial benefits become more important [27 Jul 2011]
Leaders’ Weaknesses [4 Jul 2011]
Recruitment challenges from the skills gap [25 May 2011]
CSR - Can better social responsibility boost the UK economy by £17bn? [12 May 2011]
Private v Public Sector - A Clash of Two Cultures? [20 Apr 2011]
Partners in profit - the JLP way [10 Mar 2011]
8 minutes of Daniel Pink on What Motivates Workers [7 Mar 2011]
On-the-job-training - The Come Fly With Me approach [23 Jan 2011]
How technology is changing the recruitment process [17 Jan 2011]
Training, social immobility and tuition fees - KPMG’s blueprint solution [13 Jan 2011]
Q&A - What is absenteeism and what can businesses do about it? [28 Dec 2010]
Starbucks - Two Examples of Financial and Non-Financial Methods of Motivation [19 Dec 2010]
BUSS1 Revision Quiz - Employing People [14 Dec 2010]
Bruce Poon Tip exploits a huge Gap in the adventure market [12 Dec 2010]
Video case study - enterprise at the sharp end [27 Nov 2010]
A great example of off-the-job-training - Starbucks Coffee College [16 Oct 2010]
Maltesers and Motivation [8 Oct 2010]
The business cost of labour turnover [7 Oct 2010]
Can performance-related pay motivate the SCD celebs? [18 Jul 2010]
Is this the worst job in the world? [15 Jul 2010]
Customer Service - What Students Can Learn from John Lewis Partnership [12 Jun 2010]
Are fringe benefits being cut? [5 Jun 2010]
Linking corporate objectives to management performance - the Vodafone way [4 Jun 2010]
Managing People - Will Staff Turnover Increase as the UK Emerges from the Recession [2 Jun 2010]
Flexible Working More Popular than Bonuses as a Source of Staff Motivation [2 Jun 2010]
The Dark Side of the iPad and iPhone? [26 May 2010]
Motivation, Leadership & Culture: Ban the Boss (BBC) [24 Mar 2010]
Motivation and management at John Lewis [11 Mar 2010]
HRM priorities as firms exit the recession [27 Feb 2010]
Strategy in the UK Recession - What 69 UK CEOs Did About It [22 Feb 2010]
Strategies for the Recession - Insights from Six Restaurant Group CEOs [19 Feb 2010]
Managing a recruitment business through the recession [16 Feb 2010]
Government support for apprenticeships [6 Feb 2010]
Leadership sets the culture for a thriving retail brand [31 Jan 2010]
Can bluetooth replace recruitment agencies in the battle to find job applicants [18 Jan 2010]
Revision presentation - motivation in theory [17 Jan 2010]
Revision presentation - motivation in practice [17 Jan 2010]
Revision presentation - recruitment & selection [17 Jan 2010]
Revision Presentation - Training [17 Jan 2010]
HR manager sentenced for lying about qualifications: useful recruitment and selection resource [6 Jan 2010]
Revision Presentation - Recruitment for a New Business [30 Dec 2009]
Teaching Motivation - Classic Video(s) [17 Dec 2009]
Starter Video Clip for Motivation [17 Nov 2009]
The UK: A nation of accidental managers [10 Nov 2009]
School for Santas [7 Nov 2009]
Q&A - What is Leadership? [30 Oct 2009]
A Recruitment Classic - Job Interviewing the David Brent Way [28 Oct 2009]
Leadership styles in action - Dead Poets Society [28 Oct 2009]
The gentle touch in city finance [14 Oct 2009]
Motivation in action - the stairs theory [12 Oct 2009]
Forget motivation theory - lets try to demotivate people [5 Oct 2009]
Motivation in practice - how not to do it - lessons from Britain’s bosses [1 Sep 2009]
Picking from a growing pool of job hunters [19 Aug 2009]
Recruitment & selection gets scary [27 Jul 2009]
Job applications please - but no more than 160 letters long… [6 Jul 2009]
Planning for a winning team [24 Jun 2009]
Work For Free? Or Pie In The Sky? [16 Jun 2009]
Situations Vacant - Apprentice Supervisor [10 Jun 2009]
Q&A - Explain “delayering” [1 Jun 2009]
Motivating employees - the end of the mobile phone sales shark? [17 May 2009]
Motivation in Action - Is this the Worlds Best Job? [7 May 2009]
Q&A - What is training? [2 May 2009]
Q&A - What is job enlargement? [1 May 2009]
Q&A - Explain Taylor’s theories of motivation at work [1 May 2009]
Q&A - How does a business benefit from having a well-motivated workforce? [1 May 2009]
Q&A - What is motivation? [1 May 2009]
Q&A - Why are job descriptions and specifications important? [1 May 2009]
Q&A - What is the recruitment process? [1 May 2009]
Q&A - What is involved in a training strategy? [1 May 2009]
Video case study - Google’s Non-Financial Methods of Motivation [6 Feb 2009]
Linking customer service and motivation theory [2 Feb 2009]
Video case study - starting a business in a recession [24 Jan 2009]
Video case study - Nissan [24 Oct 2008]
Selling is the way to respond to a recession [13 Oct 2008]
Arsene Wenger reveals the secrets of successful teamwork [24 Sep 2008]
Wanna job? Get down to McDonalds [18 Aug 2008]
Marketing strategy - making the pier stand out from the crowd [13 Aug 2008]
Starting a business - have your cake and eat it [6 Aug 2008]
Print advertising takes the hit as advertisers cut back [26 Jul 2008]
Is training the key to survival in a downturn? [13 Jul 2008]
Porkie Pies Don’t Cut It in the Real Job Market [15 Jun 2008]
New rights for temporary staff [20 May 2008]
The Challenge of Recruiting for the Best Job in the World (OCR Applied Unit 9) [1 Apr 2008]
The Business Studies Lessons from Terminal 5 [30 Mar 2008]
Counting the Cost of Workplace Sickness [17 Mar 2008]
John Lewis staff bag a bumper bonus [7 Mar 2008]
BUSINESS TEACHER RESOURCE NEWSLETTER
Get first news of business teaching resources, ideas and other materials from tutor2u. Over 9,400 business teachers from the UK and around the world receive our regular teacher email newsletters. Sign up for free here!
Popular Topic Tags
recession, demand, prices, price, unemployment, profit, economics, costs, investment, inflation, supply, employment, trade, competition, gdp, risk, china, debt, euro, entrepreneur, capacity, production, innovation, downturn, tutor2u, revision, pay, exports, manufacturing, confidence, profits, food, incentives, banks, strategy, globalisation, aqa, expectations, oil, csr, usa, startup, retailers, housing, productivity, sterling, supermarkets, takeover, google, economies of scale, mortgage, cash flow, advertising, quiz, leadership, property, buss4, tesco, economic growth, video, efficiency, enterprise, motivation, stakeholders, apple, deflation, corporate social responsibility, ebea, market share, airlines, pricing, taxation, merger, slowdown, bank of england, acquisition, interest rates, market failure, borrowing, competitiveness, sustainability, product life cycle, credit crunch, budget deficit, aqa business studies, facebook, twitter, aqa business, bbc, nelson thornes, philip allan updates, starbucks, philip allan, monopoly, diversification, recruitment, organic growth, stocks, training, oligopoly, starter activity, shareholders, uk economy, poverty, emerging markets, dollar, government failure, retailing, management, suppliers, buss1, marketing mix, tim harford, cpi, branding, opportunity cost, breakeven, government spending, hodder education, vat, product, customer service, eu, losses, wages, evaluation, india, external growth, wealth, environment, edexcel, location, promotion, technology, information failure, business studies revision, sources of finance, franchise, aqa gce business, elasticity, regulation, spare capacity, welfare, jobs, economic cycle, marketing, zondle, strategic direction, british airways,View all tags for the Business Blog
