How can the same product be cheaper to buy new than second-hand?

Here’s a pricing conundrum.  Which product is now sometimes available for a lower price if you buy brand new than if you buy the same product second-hand?

The answer, according to this piece in the Times, is a car.

The article quotes data from Parkers (an authoritative source on car prices) which highlights ten car models where the new car price is lower than the average second-hand price.

This doesn’t seem to make sense.  Or does it?

The answer lies in who the seller is.

New cars are sold by the dealer network.  As demand for new cars has slumped in the last 6-9 months, car manufacturers and their dealers have been left with substantial stocks of unsold vehicles.  Even after taking measures to reduce factory production, those excess stocks still need shifting.  So the dealer network is offering substantial discounts and other price-based incentives for customers to buy new. The new car market has excess supply.

On the other hand, the used car market has excess demand for some models.  There is a shortage of some models, but a good flow of customers searching the used-car websites and other distribution channels in search of what they expect will be better value.  If only they took the time to check out the new car price at the dealer.

This unusual interaction of demand and supply can’t last forever.  But hopefully it will hand around for a few more weeks whilst I complete my search for the next family car.

Revision Presentation - Marketing Mix: Introduction to Pricing [17 May 2012]
It’s Back! Datsun Makes a Comeback [26 Mar 2012]
Legislation forces Coke and Pepsi to change their recipe [9 Mar 2012]
Pampering - demand booms as consumers seek an affordable treat [4 Mar 2012]
Revision Presentation - Workforce Planning [26 Dec 2011]
Time for this Dragon to Cut Costs to Keep his Health Clubs Fighting Fit [11 Dec 2011]
Cut price cup cake deal goes wrong…... [22 Nov 2011]
Unilever hit by rising costs [6 Nov 2011]
Edexcel A2 Business Unit 4a - Toyota Case Study Toolkit [14 Sep 2011]
Nurofen Plus and the importance of quality - [28 Aug 2011]
British manufacturer exploiting a niche [21 Jun 2011]
Lean and mean - from Toyota to Tesco [10 Jun 2011]
An end to outsourcing? [18 May 2011]
Capacity cuts at Toyota UK as production still hit after Japanese earthquake [20 Apr 2011]
Kate & Wills - A Short-term boost to demand [9 Apr 2011]
JIT - How lean production suffers from a terrible shock [22 Mar 2011]
Marketing meets Sources of Finance! [20 Mar 2011]
Protection for the endangered pasty [23 Feb 2011]
Revision games - Marketing Basics (True / False) [16 Feb 2011]
Michael Porter - Shared Value and the Limitations of CSR [15 Feb 2011]
Commodity prices in action - soaring Copper [6 Feb 2011]
Q&A - Distinguish between price and cost [2 Jan 2011]
Q&A - Should a business use a “loss leader” as part of its pricing tactics? [31 Dec 2010]
Product innovation in motoring - the mass market electric car [19 Nov 2010]
Segmentation & Pricing - the Ice-Cream Price Pyramid [17 Nov 2010]
Cash flow Clue-doh! The Mystery is Revealed… [2 Nov 2010]
Making the FT Brand Sweat! [19 Oct 2010]
Analysing the Business Data - Marriage in Decline [19 Oct 2010]
Nissan Goes for it In China [20 Sep 2010]
Who ate all the pies? [17 Sep 2010]
Pricing Strategy - Mobile Data Networks [14 Sep 2010]
Strategy in Action - Crocs Comes Back from the Dead [4 Sep 2010]
Lost in translation - demand from public sector to dry up? [4 Aug 2010]
Nissan profits from a recovery in demand [30 Jul 2010]
Demand for Foreign Holidays Takes a Sharp Dip [14 Jul 2010]
Lessons from the business model of King & Allen [13 Jul 2010]
World Cup 2010 Business Winners and Losers [13 Jul 2010]
Toyota UK fights back with tv & Youtube advertising campaign on quality [26 Jun 2010]
Emerging from Recession - Manufacturing Leads the Way [1 Jun 2010]
British vodka beats the world! [19 May 2010]
The dangers of focus on one product [9 May 2010]
Build a Tower - Build a Team [22 Apr 2010]
Corus chief calls for more government funds for the economy [8 Apr 2010]
Quality Control, the old fashioned way [21 Mar 2010]
BUSS4 Research - a Corus of Disapproval [1 Mar 2010]
Managing a recruitment business through the recession [16 Feb 2010]
Amazing Production Video [15 Feb 2010]
Taking Demand-based Pricing To Extremes [8 Feb 2010]
Video case study - substitute goods benefiting from the recession [1 Feb 2010]
Strategy in a recession - Fusion Systems [1 Feb 2010]
Business priorities in a recession [1 Feb 2010]
Flexible working thrives in the recession [1 Feb 2010]
What business students can learn from how businesses have handled the recession [1 Feb 2010]
Demand and Supply in Sction - Haggis [25 Jan 2010]
Product, pricing and profitability in a changing market [20 Jan 2010]
Revision Presentation - Revenues and Demand [30 Dec 2009]
Q&A - When is it appropriate for a firm to use penetration pricing? [21 Dec 2009]
Q&A - Explain price skimming [21 Dec 2009]
Q&A - What is the difference between pricing strategies & tactics? [21 Dec 2009]
Q&A - Explain what is meant by price positioning [21 Dec 2009]
Q&A - What factors should a business consider when setting its prices? [19 Dec 2009]
Q&A - How does pricing link to the objectives of a business? [19 Dec 2009]
Q&A - What is price and why is it so important in the marketing mix? [19 Dec 2009]
Video Case Study - Luxury Sound Maker Ditches CDs [4 Dec 2009]
Outdoor Ice-skating heads firmly down the product life cycle [3 Dec 2009]
Operations in Action - Video Tour of the Amazon Depot [23 Nov 2009]
A tale of two bakers [16 Nov 2009]
Emerging markets drive demand for oil [16 Nov 2009]
Brompton Bicycles - Guardian Profile [9 Nov 2009]
Survive and prosper - emerging markets in the global recession [5 Nov 2009]
Emerging Markets - China’s Growth in Charts [5 Nov 2009]
Halloween - packed full of business studies lesson ideas [3 Nov 2009]
Santa goes back to basics in attempt to reduce the cost of Christmas [29 Oct 2009]
Q&A - What is globalisation? [27 Oct 2009]
Q&A - How are businesses affected by unemployment? [27 Oct 2009]
Q&A - What are the main causes of unemployment? [27 Oct 2009]
Q&A - Explain what unemployment is and how it is measured [27 Oct 2009]
Managing Cash Flow - Beware the Economic Recovery [26 Oct 2009]
Economist on Lean Production [20 Oct 2009]
Pricing strategies and tactics under investigation [15 Oct 2009]
Dyson launches a new premium product [14 Oct 2009]
Ukraine 1 England 0 - A match to remember? [12 Oct 2009]
Napster - Trying to compete, or getting desperate? [9 Oct 2009]
V-Water - from start up to exit [4 Oct 2009]
Strictly and X-Factor Drive Demand for Pizza [1 Oct 2009]
The lights go out for the nightclub market [26 Sep 2009]
A textbook example of how rising unemployment affects demand [23 Sep 2009]
Demand is booming for UK Cinemas [16 Sep 2009]
Video case study: battling for survival in the restaurant trade [31 Aug 2009]
Sony cuts the PS3 price to extend its life cycle [30 Aug 2009]
A dramatic fall in business investment [27 Aug 2009]
More trouble in the skies [27 Aug 2009]
Strategic business decision-making - Network Rail [26 Aug 2009]
Plastic car is a blast from the past [25 Aug 2009]
Sainsbury’s and Diageo pitch in to battle [17 Aug 2009]
Own label brands profit from the recession [4 Aug 2009]
Demand and supply in action - tea prices surge [4 Aug 2009]
Banks lend more and charge more at the same time [3 Aug 2009]
When the Steel Town Boomed [3 Aug 2009]
The Death of Newspapers - to be replaced by Nichepapers? [2 Aug 2009]

BUSINESS TEACHER RESOURCE NEWSLETTER
Get first news of business teaching resources, ideas and other materials from tutor2u. Over 9,400 business teachers from the UK and around the world receive our regular teacher email newsletters. Sign up for free here!