Branded coffee shops prove resilient to the UK recession

A very useful article in the Feb 2010 edition of Cafe Culture (the trade magazine for the cafe industry) has explained what a winning strategy has been in the UK coffee shop market during the recession.

The overall conclusion from market researchers Allegra Strategies is that the UK branded coffee shop market has proved pretty resilient to the economic downturn.  Although the rapid growth of the market in recent years has now slowed, 2009 still provided successful operators with some growth opportunities to exploit.

According to Allegra, there are around 11,000 coffee outlets in the UK, of which 4,158 (at the end of 2009) are branded (e.g. Starbucks, Costa, Caffe Nero).  The branded coffee shops have a turnover of £1.63 billion.  Revenues in the segment rose by 6.2% in 2009, compared with 12.6% growth in 2008.  The net number of new outlets rose by 258 in 2009, a 6.6% increase.  So you can see that volume growth (as measured by new outlets) was a key driver in the small rise in market sales. 

Like-for-like sales (a comparable way of measuring sales for outlets that were open in both 2008 and 2009) were broadly static.  But that statistic hides a disparity between the best-performing chains (where LFL revenues grow by between 1-2%) and the rest, where LFL sales declined.

Might we have expected coffee market revenues to have declined during 2009?  After all, GDP fell by almost 5% in 2009, partly due to much weaker consumer (and retail) spending?  The answer is that UK consumers did not abandon their coffee treats in 2009.  They continued to visit almost as frequently as in 2008, but preferred to “trade down” to lower-price items or take advantage of greater price promotions.

Some commentators in the media have found the resilience of the coffee shop market to be a surprise during the recession.  Surely, they argue, a trip to Starbucks or Costa Coffee is a discretionary spend (perhaps even a luxury) that cash-strapped consumers can do without?

However, Allegra’s detailed research into customer attitudes reveals a significant change in customer behaviour in recent years.  Cafe or coffee shop culture is now so entrenched in the UK that consumers are reluctant to cut back on what many now consider to be a necessity, or day-to-day staple.  The daily coffee fix is something that customers are unlikely to give up, even if some of them have become more price-conscious.

Allegra found that the average spend by a visitor to a branded coffee shop fell slightly in 2009, from £3.59 in 2008 to £3.50.  Partly this was due to a reduction in the proportion of customers who bought food with their coffee.  It also reflected greater price competition in the market.  For example, Starbucks lowered its UK prices below the £2 level for the first time in its history in 2009.

Marketing case study: the Swiss Army knife [24 May 2012]
Revision Presentation - Marketing Mix: Introduction to Products & Brands [17 May 2012]
Marketing analysis: the UK supermarket battleground [3 May 2012]
Brand Logos (there’s an app for that) [20 Apr 2012]
Leadership - meet the new boss of Starbucks UK [17 Apr 2012]
Revision Presentation - Unemployment & Business [6 Apr 2012]
Revision Presentation - Business Cycle and Economic Growth [6 Apr 2012]
Revision Presentation - Retrenchment [4 Apr 2012]
“Strategy is Choice” - Takeovers are Just One Option [25 Mar 2012]
Starbucks acquisition provides the base for entry into the juice bar market [25 Mar 2012]
Starbucks chooses strategic alliance in bid to enter the Indian market [13 Mar 2012]
Pampering - demand booms as consumers seek an affordable treat [4 Mar 2012]
Economics for Business: Is an economic recovery underway? [28 Feb 2012]
Strategic change - the story of Whitbread [22 Feb 2012]
Starbucks growth - three out of four ain’t bad! [30 Jan 2012]
Strategic choice: What should Facebook do with cash from the IPO? [30 Jan 2012]
Schultz on Leadership, Love and the Competitive Advantage of Culture [29 Jan 2012]
Growth strategy - Starbucks eyes the franchise model [28 Jan 2012]
Tesco takes it ‘easy’, controlling costs in its US operations [11 Jan 2012]
Strategies to revive the High Street: Mary Portas reports [13 Dec 2011]
Who do you think should be named Brand of the Year 2011? [22 Nov 2011]
Nationwide gets “Streetwise” with it’s marketing [17 Nov 2011]
Batten down the hatches - strategies for the next downturn [24 Oct 2011]
Greggs, Sausage Rolls and the Ansoff Matrix [20 Oct 2011]
Shoppers switch stores as income patterns change [11 Oct 2011]
How Mattel & Hot Wheels ‘activated boys of all ages’ [19 Sep 2011]
Coming to a petrol station near you - Little Waitrose [12 Sep 2011]
Skype CEO on Aims, Growth, Risks and Motivation [4 Sep 2011]
Risk-free Curry? Searching for the Right Growth Strategy [29 Aug 2011]
Wi-Fi - Adding value to a latte or cappuccino [25 Aug 2011]
Taking Italian to the Chinese - Pizza Express Expansion Strategy [24 Aug 2011]
Beware of the Kunming’s Rotten Apple [21 Jul 2011]
ResearchBuster: Organic Growth [7 Jun 2011]
Organic growth strategy - the benefits if firms “believe in better” [24 May 2011]
Profit, not external growth, should be the sensible strategy? [22 May 2011]
Strategy explained - Insights into Amazon [13 May 2011]
Tesco’s overseas strategy: next steps [10 May 2011]
Whitbread goes for organic growth [2 May 2011]
Tesco -  The right strategy in the US? [23 Apr 2011]
Discounters move into UK shopping malls [19 Apr 2011]
Is the golf business coming out of the bunker? [7 Apr 2011]
Recession?  Hair today, gone tomorrow [6 Apr 2011]
The UK Economy - Economic Growth GDP [15 Mar 2011]
The UK Economy - Unemployment [13 Mar 2011]
Howard Schultz - A Changed Starbucks. A Changed C.E.O [13 Mar 2011]
The Profit Margin Bloodbath of UK Recession [6 Mar 2011]
Superb Analysis of the UK Coffee Market [5 Mar 2011]
CSR at the Movies - Black Gold [23 Feb 2011]
External growth - Diageo on the acquisition trail [21 Feb 2011]
Nestle - using branding & productivity to overcome commodity price increases [17 Feb 2011]
Exporting - No Thanks - We’re British [9 Feb 2011]
Technology in business - RFID takes on the counterfeiters [6 Feb 2011]
The Strategy Battle of 2011 - David’s kid brother versus Goliath [17 Jan 2011]
Starbucks and our hostility to rebranding [17 Jan 2011]
The coffee chain formerly known as Starbucks [6 Jan 2011]
Small firms are embracing exporting - but still put off by “red tape” [29 Dec 2010]
Q&A - Should a business use franchising as part of its growth strategy? [21 Dec 2010]
Q&A - Explain “organic” or internal growth [21 Dec 2010]
Q&A - How can the expansion of a firm be measured? [21 Dec 2010]
Starbucks - Two Examples of Financial and Non-Financial Methods of Motivation [19 Dec 2010]
Marketing strategy: North Face aims to become the “Nike of outdoors” [12 Dec 2010]
Schultz on Starbucks Growth Strategy and the China Opportunity [3 Dec 2010]
Globalisation and Indian Coffee Houses [27 Nov 2010]
Dominos Pizza - Growth & Strategy (Part 3) - Smart Marketing [26 Nov 2010]
Dominos Pizza - Growth & Strategy (Part 1) - Driving Competitive Advantage [26 Nov 2010]
Euro Disney - an HRM & Finance Nightmare? [24 Nov 2010]
Recession-proof production at Fiat [20 Nov 2010]
JCB - A Great Case Study for Business Students [19 Nov 2010]
Starbucks goes for vertical integration to fuel growth in China [18 Nov 2010]
Cash flow Clue-doh! The Mystery is Revealed… [2 Nov 2010]
Start-ups - a surge in new businesses post recession [2 Nov 2010]
A great example of off-the-job-training - Starbucks Coffee College [16 Oct 2010]
Google, Profits and Diversification [16 Oct 2010]
Gap’s new logo lasts…one week [12 Oct 2010]
Google on the changing face of advertising [8 Oct 2010]
Lesson Worksheet - Business Growth Basics [29 Sep 2010]
Lesson Starter - Brand Logo Bingo (1) [19 Sep 2010]
Who ate all the pies? [17 Sep 2010]
Businesses prepare for the double-dip [13 Sep 2010]
Adding value…to the humble toilet roll [2 Sep 2010]
Can small firms shrug off their recession trauma? [2 Sep 2010]
Organic growth - Greggs CEO Outlines His Strategy [30 Aug 2010]
A beginners guide to GDP [30 Aug 2010]
The links between Physics and Marketing [29 Aug 2010]
Recession Strategy - Manufacturing Emerges Leaner and Fitter [25 Aug 2010]
The FT and Online Paywalls - a Winning Strategy? [30 Jul 2010]
Nissan profits from a recovery in demand [30 Jul 2010]
Tyrrells Entrepreneur Does it Again - with Vodka! [14 Jul 2010]
Tracking the popularity of global brands on social networks [13 Jul 2010]
The Caffe Nero Loyalty Scheme - Simple and Effective [13 Jul 2010]
Dark days for the UK nightclub market [21 Jun 2010]
AQA BUSS4 Section B Practice Question - Starbucks [15 Jun 2010]
Emerging Stronger - How UK Businesses Responded to the Recession [14 Jun 2010]
BUSS4 - Recession Strategy Lessons from Four Female Entrepreneurs [6 Jun 2010]
Emerging from Recession - Manufacturing Leads the Way [1 Jun 2010]
Long Product Life Cycles - Grocery Brands Stand the Test of Time [26 May 2010]
Strategy Case Study - Vauxhall/Opel restructuring [24 May 2010]
Howard Schultz on Starbuck’s Growth Prospects in China [19 May 2010]
British vodka beats the world! [19 May 2010]
BUSS4 UK Recession - Data Burn [15 May 2010]

BUSINESS TEACHER RESOURCE NEWSLETTER
Get first news of business teaching resources, ideas and other materials from tutor2u. Over 9,400 business teachers from the UK and around the world receive our regular teacher email newsletters. Sign up for free here!